All things are poisons, for there is nothing without poisonous qualities. It is only the dose which makes a thing poison.” ― Paracelsus

万物都是毒药,因为没有毒药就没有什么。 只是使事物中毒的剂量。” ― 寄生虫

执行摘要(又名TL; DR) (Executive Summary (aka TL;DR))

  • Most of the illegal health products reported in Singapore are marketed for sexual enhancement and weight loss.新加坡报道的大多数非法保健产品都是为了增强性欲和减肥而销售的。
  • Majority of the illegal drugs are labelled in Chinese大部分非法药物都标有中文
  • The most common dosage form design is that of a green oblong capsule最常见的剂型设计是绿色椭圆形胶囊
  • The top 5 most common adulterants are Sildenafil, Sibutramine, Tadalafil, Phenolphthalein, and Lignocaine前5种最常见的掺杂剂是西地那非,西布曲明,他达拉非,酚酞和利格卡因

背景与动机 (Background and Motivation)

The lucrative nature of peddling counterfeit and adulterated drugs has led to the proliferation of the global trade of illegal health products. This is also driven by an increase in consumer demand for these products, and the low cost in purchasing them. The obvious downside is that the consumption of these health products purchased from dubious sources run the risk of causing serious health problems to the consumers.

兜售假冒伪劣药品的有利可图的性质导致了全球非法保健产品贸易的扩散。 消费者对这些产品的需求增加以及购买它们的低成本也推动了这一点。 明显的不利因素是,从可疑来源购买的这些健康产品的消费可能会给消费者带来严重的健康问题。

These products often contain undeclared ingredients to enhance the effects to entice consumers to take them. These ingredients may be hazardous (especially if taken without medical supervision), over- or under- dosed, banned or have not been assessed for safe use in humans.

这些产品通常含有未申报的成分,以增强效果以吸引消费者服用。 这些成分可能是危险的(尤其是在未经医学监督的情况下服用),剂量过大或不足,被禁止或未经评估可安全用于人类。

In a bid to better understand the illegal health product trade in Singapore, I decided to conduct an analysis of the publicly released list of detected and tested illegal health products reported by the Health Sciences Authority (HSA).

为了更好地了解新加坡的非法健康产品贸易,我决定对由卫生科学局(HSA)报告的已公开检测和测试的非法健康产品清单进行分析。

This analysis was sparked by a conversation I had with a fellow Entrepreneur First cohort member (Shrey Chaturvedi), when we were discussing about potential problems to tackle in the Southeast Asia counterfeit drug market. I decided it was a good opportunity to work on this mini-project related to what I enjoy — the intersection of drugs and data.

我与一位企业家第一组同事(Shrey Chaturvedi)进行的一次对话引发了这种分析,当时我们正在讨论东南亚假药市场需要解决的潜在问题。 我认为这是一个与我所喜欢的药物和数据相关的小型项目的好机会。

第一部分-数据采购 (Part I — Sourcing for Data)

The database for illegal health products reported by the HSA is available for public viewing on this page. Although this list is not exhaustive, it still serves as a reasonable sample of all the illegal health products being traded in Singapore.

HSA报告的非法保健产品数据库可在此页面上公开查看。 尽管此列表并不详尽,但仍可以作为在新加坡交易的所有非法健康产品的合理样本。

This dataset is presented as a data table on the site, and was accessed and retrieved on 15th August 2020.

该数据集以站点数据表的形式显示,并于2020年8月15日被访问和检索。

Screenshot of HSA Illegal Health Products Database Search ResultsHSA非法保健产品数据库搜索结果的屏幕截图

The features available are as follows:

可用功能如下:

Table of dataset features (columns) and respective description数据集特征(列)表及其说明

The contents of the database on the site was manually transcribed and saved as an Excel (.xlsx) file with the use of Notepad++ and Microsoft Excel. This was then imported into Jupyter Notebook for further analysis using Python 3.

使用Notepad ++和Microsoft Excel手动转录了站点上数据库的内容,并将其保存为Excel( .xlsx )文件。 然后将其导入Jupyter Notebook,以使用Python 3进行进一步分析。

Having come across street side counterfeit drug peddlers while overseas on holiday, my initial hypothesis is that these counterfeit drugs are mainly lifestyle products. In particular, the ‘best-seller’ is likely sex-enhancement drugs targeted at the adult male population.

我在国外度假时遇到街头假冒伪劣药品的小贩,我最初的假设是这些假冒伪劣药品主要是生活用品。 特别是,“畅销产品”可能是针对成年男性人群的性增强药物。

第二部分-数据清理 (Part II — Data Cleaning)

There are a total of 245 reported illegal health products documented in the HSA Illegal Health Products database at the time of this writing.

在撰写本文时,HSA非法健康产品数据库中记录了总共245个报告的非法健康产品。

All 54 rows with null values in the ‘Dosage Form’ column were associated with tablets as displayed in the respective ‘Product Description’ column. These null values were thus filled with ‘Tablet’ as a dosage form entry, thereby creating a new Dosage Form category of ‘Tablet’ not utilized previously. The count of null values for each column in the final dataset is shown below:

“剂量表”列中所有具有值的54行都与相应的“产品说明”列中显示的片剂相关联。 因此,将这些值填充为“片剂”作为剂型条目,从而创建以前未使用的“片剂”的新剂型类别。 最终数据集中每列的值计数如下所示:

Frequency count of null values for each column
每列空值的频率计数

The null values for shape and color were mainly due to products packaged as vials and bottles, which are harder to characterize as compared to the usual oral tablets or capsules.

形状和颜色的值主要是由于包装为小瓶和瓶子的产品,与普通的口服片剂或胶囊剂相比,它们更难以表征。

Given that there was plenty of missing data in the ‘Remarks for Dosage Form Marking’ column (i.e. 61.2% NA), the review of product markings was omitted in this analysis.

鉴于“剂型标记说明”列中有大量缺失数据(即61.2 NA ),因此在此分析中省略了对产品标记的审查。

There were 13 products with dosage form stated as ‘Pill’, which was an uninformative categorization. The product images were reviewed manually to determine its exact dosage form (i.e. tablet or capsule).

有13个产品的剂型称为“药丸”,属于非信息性分类。 手动检查产品图像以确定其确切剂型(即片剂或胶囊剂)。

第三部分-探索性数据分析的见解 (Part III — Insights from Exploratory Data Analysis)

Now to the main part of this analysis, which is the patterns and findings observed.

现在到此分析的主要部分,即观察到的模式和发现。

(i)产品说明 ((i) Product Description)

The product description gives the name of the product, along with some useful (albeit brief) information about its intended use for the consumer. Given that we are dealing with text strings here, it would be a good idea to use a word cloud generator (with Python WordCloud library) to illustrate the text frequency in these descriptions.

产品说明给出了产品名称,以及一些有关其预期用途的有用(尽管很简短)信息。 鉴于我们在这里处理文本字符串,最好使用词云生成器(带有Python WordCloud库)来说明这些描述中的文本频率。

After removing uninformative stop words (e.g. ‘Brand’, ‘Capsule’, ‘Jiao Nang’ (which means capsule in Chinese) ‘Tablet’), the following word cloud was produced:

删除无用的停用词(例如“ Brand”,“ Capsule”,“ Jiao Nang”(中文是胶囊)“ Tablet”)后,产生了以下词云:

Full word cloud for Product Description产品描述的完整文字云

It is clear that most of these words are romanization of Chinese characters (i.e. Hanyu Pinyin). This suggests that many products are mainly labelled in Chinese, and interpreting this full word cloud is not the best way to understand the nature of these products.

显然,这些单词大多数是汉字(即汉语拼音 )的罗马化。 这表明许多产品主要以中文标记,并且解释完整的单词云并不是了解这些产品性质的最佳方法。

Given that the word cloud suggests a high occurrence of Chinese characters, it would be interesting to see the proportion of the illegal health products containing Chinese characters in their product description.

鉴于“云”一词表明汉字的出现率很高,因此很有趣的是,在其产品说明中看到含有汉字的非法保健产品所占的比例。

Proportion of illegal health products containing Chinese characters in product description
产品说明中含有汉字的非法保健品比例

It can be seen that the list of illegal drugs is dominated by products labeled in Chinese (73.5%). This might imply that either the Chinese population is the primary target group for illegal drug dealers, or that these products are sourced primarily from China.

可以看出,非法药物清单以中文标签产品占主导(73.5%)。 这可能意味着中国人口是非法毒品交易者的主要目标人群,或者这些产品主要来自中国。

The next step is to generate a Chinese character word cloud. This was done by first using regular expression (regex) to extract all Chinese characters from the ‘Product Description’ column, and using Python’s jieba library to tokenize these Chinese characters. With certain Chinese stop words removed (e.g. 胶囊), the WordCloud library was used once again to generate a word cloud:

下一步是生成汉字词云。 首先,使用正则表达式( regex )从“产品描述”列中提取所有汉字,然后使用Python的jieba库对这些汉字进行标记化。 删除某些中文停用词(例如胶囊)后,再次使用WordCloud库生成词云:

containing Chinese characters in Product Description包含汉字的产品的词云

With this Chinese word cloud, it becomes easier to understand the nature of the illegal health products.

有了这个中文词云,就更容易理解非法保健产品的性质。

  • Finding 1

    发现1

    The word America (‘美国’) occurs frequently, implying that dealers tend to market their counterfeit drugs as products of USA, likely to falsely augment its appeal, quality and legitimacy towards consumers. This assertion was confirmed when I looked at these specific products containing ‘美国’, and found these products to be branded with phrases like ‘America Warrior’ and ‘America Viagra’. Another country observed in the word cloud is Germany (‘德国’), meaning that drugs produced in Germany are also associated with strong branding.

    “美国”(America,简称“ USA”)字眼经常出现,表示经销商倾向于将其假冒药品作为美国产品销售,从而有可能错误地提高其对消费者的吸引力,质量和合法性。 当我查看这些包含“美国”的特定产品并发现这些产品带有“ America Warrior”和“ America Viagra”之类的商标时,这一说法得到了证实。 在“云”一词中观察到的另一个国家是德国('德国'),这意味着在德国生产的药品也与强大的品牌效应有关。

  • Finding 2

    发现2

    The two most common claims made by these health products relate to sexual performance and male genitalia (‘牛鞭’, ‘升阳’, ‘延时’, ‘魔根’), and weight loss (‘减肥’, ‘瘦身’). This is further supported by other frequently occurring nuanced words associated with sexual vitality (‘金聖力’, ‘战神’, ‘动力’, ‘天雄’, ‘神威’).

    这些保健产品提出的两个最常见的主张与性行为和男性生殖器(“牛鞭”,“升阳”,“延迟”,“魔根”)以及体重减轻(“减肥”,“App.svelte” )。 与性活力相关的其他频繁出现的细微差别词(“金圣力”,“战神”,“动力”,“天雄”,“神威”)进一步支持了这一点。

  • Finding 3

    发现3

    There are several common words associated with dragon (‘龙牌’, ‘天龙’), which is not out of the ordinary since the dragon traditionally symbolizes potent and auspicious powers in Chinese culture.

    与“龙牌”,“天龙”相关的几个常用词并不奇怪,因为龙传统上象征着中国文化中的有力和吉祥的力量。

  • Finding 4

    发现4

    While drug names are not commonly mentioned in the Chinese descriptions, there is one obvious branded name that appeared frequently, which is Viagra (‘威哥’, ‘伟哥’).

    尽管中文描述中并未普遍提及药品名称,但经常出现一个明显的品牌名称,即“威哥”(“威哥”,“伟哥”)。

It is also important to analyse the other products that did not contain any Chinese characters, which make up 26.5% of this illegal drugs dataset. After removing English and Malay stop words (e.g. Kapsul, Obat), the generated word cloud is shown below:

分析不包含任何中文字符的其他产品也很重要,这些产品占该非法药物数据集的26.5%。 删除英语和马来停用词(例如,Kapsul,Obat)后,生成的词云如下所示:

without Chinese characters in Product Description不含汉字的产品的词云

Similar to what was seen earlier for the Chinese-labeled products, these products also appear marketed for weight loss and sexual enhancement for men. This is observed from the English words (e.g. ‘Men’, ‘Sexual’, ‘Slim’, ‘Weight’), as well as some of the suggestive Malay words (e.g. ‘Kuat’ (strong), ‘Untuk Pria’ (for men), ‘Tongkat Ali’ (herb known for its use in managing erectile dysfunction). All these insights support the earlier hypotheses that sexual enhancement drugs are the leading counterfeit products being traded.

与先前在中国贴标产品上看到的相似,这些产品也出现了针对男性减肥和增强性欲的市场。 从英语单词(例如“ Men”,“ Sexual”,“ Slim”,“ Weight”)以及一些暗示性的马来语单词(例如“ Kuat”(强),“ Untuk Pria”(例如男性),“东革阿里”(以治疗勃起功能障碍而著称的草药),所有这些见解都支持早期的假设,即性增强药物是主要的假冒产品。

  • Finding 5Another finding from the word cloud exploration is the presence of the Malay phrase ‘Asam Urat’, which means uric acid in English. High levels of uric acid in the blood is the cause of gout, and the frequent occurrence of the Malay phrase of uric acid suggests that there are many counterfeit products marketed for gout management as well.

    发现5从云探测这个词的另一个发现是存在马来语“ Asam Urat”,这在英语中表示尿酸 。 血液中高水平的尿酸是痛风的原因,而马来语的尿酸短语的频繁出现表明,市场上也有许多假冒产品用于痛风管理。

(ii) 剂量表 ((ii) Dosage Form)

The majority of these illegal health products are in oral solid dosage forms, namely capsules and tablets.

这些非法保健产品大部分以口服固体剂型存在,即胶囊剂和片剂。

Distribution of the Dosage Forms
剂型分布

This is unsurprising since oral formulations offer many advantages such as:

这并不奇怪,因为口服制剂具有许多优点,例如:

  • Ease of manufacture, packaging and transport易于制造,包装和运输
  • Good chemical and physical stability良好的化学和物理稳定性
  • Relatively low cost of production生产成本相对较低
  • Simple and accurate dosing for consumers为消费者提供简单而准确的剂量

(iii) 剂型颜色和形状 ((iii) Dosage Form Color and Shape)

Since white is the most commonly occurring color for oral medications in general, it is also not surprising to see that white is the predominant color for these illegal health products as well. The next three most common colors happen to be the standard primary colors of red, blue and green.

由于白色通常是口服药物中最常见的颜色,因此看到白色也是这些非法保健产品的主要颜色也就不足为奇了。 接下来的三种最常见的颜色恰好是红色,蓝色和绿色的标准原色。

Distribution of the Dosage Form Colors剂型颜色的分布

In terms of the dosage form shape, the predominant shape is oblong.

就剂型形状而言,主要形状是长方形

Distribution of the Dosage Form Shape剂型形状的分布

By looking at the above charts separately, you might imagine that the most common design is that of a white oblong capsule. However, we should be looking at it from the combined sequence of dosage form, color and shape. With that, it is evident that the most common dosage form design was in fact a green oblong capsule instead of a white one.

通过分别查看上面的图表,您可能会想到最常见的设计是白色长方形胶囊的设计 。 但是,我们应该从剂型,颜色和形状的组合顺序来看待它。 由此可见,最常见的剂型设计实际上是绿色的椭圆形胶囊而不是白色的椭圆形胶囊

Top 10 most common Dosage Form designs
十大最常见的剂型设计

Here is an example of what a green oblong capsule looks like:

这是一个绿色椭圆形胶囊的示例:

(iv)剂型标记 ((iv) Dosage Form Markings)

It can be seen that the majority of these illegal health products (60.6%) do not have any markings on them. This makes it all the more difficult to pinpoint the specific identity of these drugs, as well as to distinguish the counterfeit products from the real ones.

可以看出,这些非法保健产品中的大多数(60.6%)都没有任何标记。 这使得查明这些药物的具体身份以及区分假冒产品与真实产品更加困难。

Distribution of products with and without markings/engravings带有或不带有标记/雕刻的产品经销

(v) 掺假者 ((v) Adulterants)

Adulterants are the undetected and unapproved potent medicinal ingredients in the health product, and these adulterants are the main reasons why these counterfeit products are deemed illegal.

掺假品是保健产品中未经检测和未经批准的有效药用成分,这些掺假品是将这些假冒产品视为非法产品的主要原因。

These adulterants can cause serious adverse health effects owing to accidental misuse, overuse, or interaction with other medications, underlying health conditions, or other ingredients within the supplement.

这些掺假者可能由于意外误用,过度使用或与其他药物,潜在的健康状况或补充剂中的其他成分相互作用而导致严重的不利健康影响

The following table show the top 10 most common adulterants that form a part of these illegal products.

下表显示了构成这些非法产品一部分的前10名最常见的掺杂物。

Top 10 adulterants discovered in the illegal health products
在非法保健产品中发现的十大掺假

Now would be a good time to bring in some pharmacological knowledge into the fray, by describing the top 5 adulterants seen in the above table.

现在,是描述一些在上表中列出的前五种掺杂剂的好时机,将一些药理学知识引入竞争。

(1) SildenafilWhat is it? Sildenafil is by far the most common adulterant found in illegal health products. Sildenafil is the generic name of the active compound found in Viagra (brand name), and is used to treat erectile dysfunction (ED).

(1)西地那非是什么? 迄今为止,西地那非是在非法保健产品中最常见的掺假品。 西地那非是在伟哥中发现的活性化合物的通用名称(商标名称),用于治疗勃起功能障碍(ED)。

Fun Fact: Sildenafil was originally developed for the treatment of pulmonary hypertension and angina pectoris (chest pain due to heart disease). However, during the clinical trials, researchers found the drug to be more effective at inducing erections than treating angina.

有趣的事实:西地那非最初开发用于治疗肺动脉高压和心绞痛(由于心脏病引起的胸痛)。 但是,在临床试验期间,研究人员发现该药物比引起心绞痛更有效地诱发勃起。

Side Effects: While most side effects are generally mild (e.g. flushing, headaches), there is a risk of more severe reactions such as vision loss, priapism (persistent and painful erection), and severe hypotension. These risks are certainly amplified when consuming these counterfeit products, whereby the dosages contained within them are poorly regulated.

副作用:虽然大多数副作用通常是轻度的(例如潮红,头痛),但存在更严重的React的风险,例如视力丧失,阴茎异常勃起(持续性和疼痛性勃起)以及严重的低血压 。 当消费这些假冒产品时,这些风险肯定会加剧,从而限制了其中所含的剂量。

(2) SibutramineWhat is it? Sibutramine is a compound used for weight loss. This supports the insights gathered earlier that weight loss is a common area which illegal health products tend to target. Sibutramine works by increasing thermogenesis and making the user feel fuller after a meal, and it has mainly been studied in obese patient populations.

(2) 西布曲明是什么? 西布曲明是用于减肥的化合物。 这支持了早先收集到的见识,即减肥是非法保健产品往往针对的常见领域。 西布曲明通过增加产热作用和使用户饭后感觉更饱满而起作用,并且主要在肥胖患者人群中进行了研究。

Side Effects: It is known to be associated with an increased risk of cardiovascular events like heart attack, stroke and hypertension.

副作用:已知与心血管事件(心脏病发作,中风和高血压)的 风险增加 有关。

(3) TadalafilWhat is it? Being in the same drug class as Sildenafil (i.e. Phosphodiesterase-5 Enzyme Inhibitors), Tadalafil is also used to treat ED, and shares many similar features with Sildenafil. Its brand name is Cialis.

(3) 他达拉非是什么? 与西地那非属于同一类药物(即磷酸二酯酶-5酶抑制剂),他达拉非也用于治疗ED,并且与西地那非具有许多相似的特征。 它的品牌名称是Cialis。

(4) PhenolphthaleinWhat is it? Phenolphthalein is a laxative, and is commonly found in adulterated weight loss products. Multiple dietary supplements containing Phenolphthalein and Sibutramine have been previously recalled by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) due to their unapproved inclusion in the supplements.

(4)酚酞是什么? 酚酞是泻药,通常在掺假减肥产品中发现。 美国食品药品监督管理局(FDA)之前曾召回多种含有酚酞和西布曲明的膳食补充剂,原因是它们未经批准地包含在其中。

Side Effects: Phenolphthalein exposure has been associated with carcinogenicity (i.e. can cause cancer).

副作用:酚酞的暴露与致癌性有关 (即可能导致癌症)。

(5) LignocaineWhat is it? Lignocaine is an anesthetic, meaning that it is a medication used to numb tissues in a specific body region when applied topically on the skin or mucous surface. It typically comes in the form of topical products (e.g. spray, gels), and is used to manage premature ejaculation due to its numbing effect.

(5)利多卡因是什么? 利诺卡因是麻醉剂,这意味着当局部应用在皮肤或粘液表面时,它是一种用于麻木特定身体区域组织的药物。 它通常以局部用药(例如喷雾剂,凝胶剂)的形式出现,由于其麻木作用而被用于处理早泄。

Side Effects: Topical use has generally mild side effects such as itch/redness, but the potentially poor quality of the illegal product may lead to unexpected hypersensitivity/allergic skin reactions.

副作用:局部使用通常会产生轻微的副作用,例如瘙痒/发红,但是非法产品的潜在质量差可能导致意外的超敏React/过敏性皮肤React。

From here, I decided to take a closer look at these Lignocaine-containing products, to confirm my hypothesis that all supplements containing Lignocaine are of the topical dosage form.

从这里开始,我决定仔细研究这些含有利诺卡因的产品,以证实我的假设,即所有含有利尼卡因的补品都是局部剂型。

Dosage Form distribution of Lignocaine-containing products
含利多卡因产品的剂型分布

Although the most common dosage form is indeed something used for topical application (liquid for external use), I was surprised to see that there were quite a number of oral capsule and tablet products containing Lignocaine as well, especially since Lignocaine is not meant for oral consumption. This is certainly something worth looking deeper into.

尽管最常见的剂型确实是局部用药(外用液体),但令我惊讶的是,有相当多的口服胶囊和片剂产品也含有利诺卡因,尤其是因为利诺卡因不适合口服消费。 这当然值得深入研究。

下一步 (Next Steps)

This analysis offers some insights into the trends and patterns observed in the illegal health product trade in Singapore, which can be of value for authorities like the HSA. For example, by understanding the common marketed claims and main groups of people targeted by illegal dealers, specially curated education campaigns can be conducted to raise awareness so that the public understands how to better protect themselves.

该分析为新加坡非法保健产品贸易中观察到的趋势和模式提供了一些见解,这对于像HSA这样的机构可能具有价值。 例如,通过了解非法经销商所针对的共同市场主张和主要人群,可以开展专门策划的教育运动以提高认识,从而使公众了解如何更好地保护自己。

Having access to more data (such as place of purchase, country of manufacture, date of reporting, profiles of peddler/consumer etc.) would also help to make this analysis more insightful and useful in tackling the peddling of such illegal products.

能够访问更多数据(例如购买地点,制造国家/地区,报告日期,小贩/消费者的个人资料等)也将有助于使该分析更具洞察力,并有助于解决此类非法产品的小贩。

整理东西 (Wrapping things up)

In reality, it can be very challenging to distinguish real products from counterfeit ones. So here is some advice from your friendly pharmacist: Always purchase your medications and health products from registered medical institutions, clinics and pharmacies. If you do encounter such illegal products being peddled, you may report it to the HSA Enforcement Branch via phone (6866 3485) or email (hsa_is@hsa.gov.sg)

实际上,将真实产品与假冒产品区分开来可能非常具有挑战性。 因此,这里有您友善的药剂师的一些建议:务必从注册的医疗机构,诊所和药房购买药物和保健品。 如果您确实遇到了此类违法产品被贩卖,则可以通过电话(6866 3485)或电子邮件(hsa_is@hsa.gov.sg)将其报告给HSA执法部门。

I look forward to hearing your feedback on the above analysis. If you would like to have a copy of the code, or wish to discuss more about this review, please feel free to drop me a message on LinkedIn!

我期待听到您对以上分析的反馈。 如果您想获得该代码的副本,或希望讨论有关此评论的更多信息,请随时在LinkedIn上给我留言!

Special thanks to Koo Ping Shung for sharing his feedback on the analysis

特别感谢 Koo Ping Shung 分享他对分析的反馈

参考书目 (Bibliography)

  • Center for Drug Evaluation and Research. (n.d.). Counterfeit Medicine. Retrieved August 15, 2020, from https://www.fda.gov/drugs/buying-using-medicine-safely/counterfeit-medicine

    药物评估和研究中心。 (nd)。 假药。 于2020年8月15日从https://www.fda.gov/drugs/buying-using-medicine-safely/counterfeit-medicine检索

  • How to identify adulterated, counterfeit and substandard health products, and what you should do. (n.d.). Retrieved August 15, 2020, from https://www.hsa.gov.sg/consumer-safety/articles/identify-adulterated-counterfeit-substandard-health-products

    如何识别掺假,假冒和不合格的保健产品,以及您应该怎么做。 (nd)。 于2020年8月15日从https://www.hsa.gov.sg/consumer-safety/articles/identify-adulterated-counterfeit-substandard-health-products检索

  • Illegal Health Products Found in Singapore. (n.d.). Retrieved August 15, 2020, from https://www.hsa.gov.sg/illegal-health-products-found-in-singapore

    在新加坡发现非法保健品。 (nd)。 于2020年8月15日从https://www.hsa.gov.sg/illegal-health-products-found-in-singapore检索

  • The dangers of adulterated, counterfeit and substandard health products. (n.d.). Retrieved August 15, 2020, from https://www.hsa.gov.sg/consumer-safety/articles/illegal-health-products

    掺假,假冒和不合格保健产品的危险。 (nd)。 于2020年8月15日从https://www.hsa.gov.sg/consumer-safety/articles/illegal-health-products检索

  • Create wordcloud with chinese. (n.d.). Retrieved August 15, 2020, from https://amueller.github.io/word_cloud/auto_examples/wordcloud_cn.html

    用中文创建wordcloud。 (nd)。 于2020年8月15日从https://amueller.github.io/word_cloud/auto_examples/wordcloud_cn.html检索

翻译自: https://towardsdatascience.com/exploring-illegal-drugs-in-singapore-a-data-perspective-3716a75ee557


http://www.taodudu.cc/news/show-997412.html

相关文章:

  • python 重启内核_Python从零开始的内核回归
  • 回归分析中自变量共线性_具有大特征空间的回归分析中的变量选择
  • python 面试问题_值得阅读的30个Python面试问题
  • 机器学习模型 非线性模型_机器学习:通过预测菲亚特500的价格来观察线性模型的工作原理...
  • pytorch深度学习_深度学习和PyTorch的推荐系统实施
  • 数据库课程设计结论_结论:
  • 网页缩放与窗口缩放_功能缩放—不同的Scikit-Learn缩放器的效果:深入研究
  • 未越狱设备提取数据_从三星设备中提取健康数据
  • 分词消除歧义_角色标题消除歧义
  • 在加利福尼亚州投资于新餐馆:一种数据驱动的方法
  • 近似算法的近似率_选择最佳近似最近算法的数据科学家指南
  • 在Python中使用Seaborn和WordCloud可视化YouTube视频
  • 数据结构入门最佳书籍_最佳数据科学书籍
  • 多重插补 均值插补_Feature Engineering Part-1均值/中位数插补。
  • 客户行为模型 r语言建模_客户行为建模:汇总统计的问题
  • 多维空间可视化_使用GeoPandas进行空间可视化
  • 机器学习 来源框架_机器学习的秘密来源:策展
  • 呼吁开放外网_服装数据集:呼吁采取行动
  • 数据可视化分析票房数据报告_票房收入分析和可视化
  • 先知模型 facebook_Facebook先知
  • 项目案例:qq数据库管理_2小时元项目:项目管理您的数据科学学习
  • 查询数据库中有多少个数据表_您的数据中有多少汁?
  • 数据科学与大数据技术的案例_作为数据科学家解决问题的案例研究
  • 商业数据科学
  • 数据科学家数据分析师_站出来! 分析人员,数据科学家和其他所有人的领导和沟通技巧...
  • 分析工作试用期收获_免费使用零编码技能探索数据分析
  • 残疾科学家_数据科学与残疾:通过创新加强护理
  • spss23出现数据消失_改善23亿人口健康数据的可视化
  • COVID-19研究助理
  • 缺失值和异常值的识别与处理_识别异常值-第一部分

从数据角度探索在新加坡的非法毒品相关推荐

  1. 网易云音乐数据治理探索与实践

    网易云音乐数据治理探索与实践 导读:大数据时代的到来,让很多企业看到了数据资产的价值,开始探索应用场景和商业模式,并建设相关技术平台.因此,数据治理成为了挖掘数据价值的重要手段和工具.但数据治理不仅需 ...

  2. 对papi家的大小咪视频数据进行探索及可视化

    对papi家的大小咪视频数据进行探索及可视化 一.数据集 二.初探数据 数据清洗 三.数据可视化 3.1 视频长度分析 3.2 昵称提及频率分析 3.3 视频标签播放量分析 3.4 视频更新频率分析 ...

  3. 「以代码作画」从数据角度剖析Art Blocks生成艺术

    作者:Mia Bao, co-founder of thepass.to, chief partner of WHALE members 数据:Jin, data analyst of thepass ...

  4. “数据资产化探索”专题

    点击上方蓝字关注我们 <中华人民共和国国民经济和社会发展第十四个五年规划和2035年远景目标纲要>中提出:建立健全数据要素市场规则.统筹数据开发利用.隐私保护和公共安全,加快建立数据资源产 ...

  5. 专题导读:数据资产化探索

    点击上方蓝字关注我们 专题导读:数据资产化探索 理查德•彼得斯于1974年就提出数据资产名词了,但至今数据资产仍然无法计入会计报表,说明数据资产化的难度非常大.这也妨害了数据的流通和再生产.随着大数据 ...

  6. 数据湖探索DLI新功能:基于openLooKeng的交互式分析

    摘要:基于华为开源openLooKeng引擎的交互式分析功能,将重磅发布便于用户构建轻量级流.批.交互式全场景数据湖. 在这个"信息爆炸"的时代,大数据已经成为这个时代的关键词之一 ...

  7. 有了数据湖探索服务,企业决策“新”中有数

    摘要:全托管Serverless服务DLI就像是我们日常使用的滴滴共享打车,我们不再需要为购买和保养私家车而支出固定成本. 1. 趋势和挑战 1.1. 趋势 随着云化技术越来越成熟,企业开始逐步上云, ...

  8. 快手短视频领域为例的领域数据建设探索

    今天给大家带来快手大数据研发专家范姝琼所做的分享<快手短视频领域为例的领域数据建设探索.pdf>,关注短视频.数据建设.领域建设的伙伴别错过啦!(到小程序中省时查报告中搜索"推荐 ...

  9. 华为云服务权限在哪_华为云数据湖探索服务DLI,精细化保障企业大数据安全

    原标题:华为云数据湖探索服务DLI,精细化保障企业大数据安全 随着企业业务的不断发展,企业大数据资产在企业辅助决策.用户画像.推荐系统等诸多业务流程中扮演着越来越重要的作用,如何保证企业大数据在满足各 ...

最新文章

  1. 学计算机须知,学习计算机须知的50个专业术语
  2. VTK:直线网格之RectilinearGrid
  3. jq第一天(1.83里面的属性)属性-》属性
  4. flex.css快速入门,极速布局
  5. 使用CodeIgniter输入类
  6. 如何卸载IE7重装IE6
  7. STLC++(队列queue、栈stack、set\multiset 的用法)
  8. C++ std::set insert 失败 原因和解决方案 operator
  9. Redis持久化的方式
  10. jmp怎么做合并的箱线图_JMP和Minitab的图形分析
  11. 数学4如何用计算机画正切函数图像,7.3.4正切函数的性质和图像
  12. 轻松访问Google Chrome浏览器中的浏览历史记录
  13. Prolog编程求解图搜索问题
  14. Win10系统隐藏文件资源管理器中的3D对象等七个文件夹
  15. 求助 NVIDIA GeForce experience安装失败
  16. 区块链和人工智能是否可以保护森林不再被砍伐?
  17. A2. Gsensor调试
  18. excle2010 一张图上画两种类型的图:折线图+柱形图
  19. c语言双序列全局比对,基于动态规划进行双序列全局比对
  20. virtualhackinglabs靶机 ANTHONY 10.12.1.113

热门文章

  1. 智能不属于计算机理论,讨论:计算机如何能提出自己的理论
  2. Arcgis 使用ArcToolbox实现数据统计
  3. [转帖]USB-C和Thunderbolt 3连接线你搞懂了吗?---没搞明白.
  4. WPF中MVVM模式的 Event 处理
  5. stack 的一些用法
  6. J - Borg Maze
  7. [转]DevExpress GridControl 关于使用CardView的一点小结
  8. uinavigation样式
  9. 【百度地图API】如何制作一张魔兽地图!!——CS地图也可以,哈哈哈
  10. [Everyday Mathematics]20150101