期刊JSS（journal of systems and software ）对评审（review process and reviewers）的要求
前言
本文旨在介绍JSS这个计算机领域的SCI期刊是怎么评审的。
评审要求（JSS期刊）
https://www.journals.elsevier.com/journal-of-systems-and-software/editorial-board
这个是JSS的editorial board，看来编辑里的中国学者也不是很多（似乎有一部分学者还是在国外大学当老师）。
[1] Elsevier for Reviewers. https://www.elsevier.com/reviewers
The peer review system exists to validate academic work, helps to improve the quality of published research, and increases networking possibilities within research communities.
peer review是为了提高论文质量。
[2] What is peer review? https://www.elsevier.com/reviewers/what-is-peer-review
Despite many criticisms about the integrity of peer review, the majority of the research community still believes peer review is the best form of scientific evaluation. This opinion was endorsed by the outcome of a survey Elsevier and Sense About Science conducted in 2009 and has since been further confirmed by other publisher and scholarly organization surveys. Furthermore, a 2015 survey by the Publishing Research Consortium, saw 82 percent of researchers agreeing that “without peer review there is no control in scientific communication.”
竟然还有很多反对peer review的人。之前并不知道有这回事。
这个网页非常给力，给了一个流程图（如下），很完美的解释了peer review的过程。
原来二审是 需要 recommend，（然后editor决定录不录）
看懂了。学到。
==The peer review process==
Single blind review
In this type of review, the names of the reviewers are hidden from the author. This is the traditional method of reviewing and is the most common type by far. Points to consider regarding single blind review include:Reviewer anonymity allows for impartial decisions – the reviewers should not be influenced by the authors.
Authors may be concerned that reviewers in their field could delay publication, giving the reviewers a chance to publish first.
Reviewers may use their anonymity as justification for being unnecessarily critical or harsh when commenting on the authors’ work.
Double-blind review
Both the reviewer and the author are anonymous in this model. Some advantages of this model are listed below.Author anonymity limits reviewer bias, for example based on an author’s gender, country of origin, academic status or previous publication history.
Articles written by prestigious or renowned authors are considered on the basis of the content of their papers, rather than their reputation.
But bear in mind that despite the above, reviewers can often identify the author through their writing style, subject matter or self-citation – it is exceedingly difficult to guarantee total author anonymity. More information for authors can be found in our double-blind peer review guidelines.
这里详细讲了一下single double blind review，但是我觉得对我用处也不是很大，不过这里还是记录一下。也是科普了一下。
Triple-blind review
With triple-blind review, reviewers are anonymous and the author’s identity is unknown to both the reviewers and the editor. Articles are anonymized at the submission stage and are handled in such a way to minimize any potential bias towards the author(s). However, it should be noted that:the complexities involved with anonymizing articles/authors to this level are considerable
as with double-blind review; there is still a possibility for the editor and/or reviewers to correctly divine the author’s identity from their style, subject matter, citation patterns or a number of other methodologies
这里还有三方盲评，厉害了。
Open review
Open peer review is an umbrella term for many different models aiming at greater transparency during and after the peer review process. The most common definition of open review is when both the reviewer and author are known to each other during the peer review process. Other types of open peer review consist of: 省略。。。Many believe this is the best way to prevent malicious comments, stop plagiarism, prevent reviewers from following their own agenda, and encourage open, honest reviewing. Others see open review as a less honest process, in which politeness or fear of retribution may cause a reviewer to withhold or tone down criticism.
还有open view，感觉还不错。
期刊JSS（journal of systems and software ）对评审（review process and reviewers）的要求相关推荐
- 期刊（Journal）、会议（Conference）及其影响因子（Impact Factor）
CNCC:China National Computer Congress,中国计算机大会 0. 会议 计算机视觉(CV)三大顶级会议: ICCV: IEEE International Confer ...
- 计算机报刊杂志推荐,计算机优秀期刊推荐 | Journal of Cloud Computing
原标题:计算机优秀期刊推荐 | Journal of Cloud Computing 本期为您推荐云计算领域的优秀期刊 Journal of Cloud Computing: Advances, Sy ...
- 计算机开源期刊International Journal of Computer Science Issues
计算机开源的一个期刊 International Journal of Computer Science Issues 网站:http://www.ijcsi.org/index.php 双月刊,至少 ...
- 新期刊《Journal of Machine Learning》上线！
全 新 期 刊 尽管在机器学习及其相关领域有很多会议,但以期刊形式发表研究工作(没有提交截止日期,且没有苛刻的页数限制)仍然是许多学科的首要选择,尤其是数学和科学领域. 最近,由鄂维南院士担任期刊主编 ...
- 农业计算机与电子是几区sci,孙致陆和李先德在院选英文SCI核心期刊《Journal of Integrative Agriculture》发表论文...
在国家自然科学基金青年项目(71703157)和中国农业科学院科技创新工程(ASTIP-IAED-2018-06)等共同资助下,我所孙致陆助理研究员为第一作者和李先德研究员为通讯作者撰写的论文< ...
- Magnetic Actuation Systems for Miniature Robots: A Review
这篇文章非常详尽地介绍了用于磁驱动的各种方法和系统,总体分为四大类,单永磁,多永磁,线圈组,分布式电磁铁组合. 用于微型机器人的磁驱动系统:回顾 Magnetic Actuation Systems ...
- 4.4.1. SWE.1 Software Requirements Analysis中“Process outcomes”的第一条的正确翻译
4.4.1. SWE.1 Software Requirements Analysis中"Process outcomes"内容: As a result of successfu ...
- SCI期刊简介:JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL CLINICAL CANCER RESEARCH
1.杂志简介 JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL & CLINICAL CANCER RESEARCH是由意大利于1982创刊,当前出版和管理杂志是由BioMed Central负 ...
- journal of systems science and complexity
https://www.springer.com/journal/11424 斯普林格
最新文章
- linux英文安装教程图解,Linux安装中英文对照小手册
- 编程建立一通讯簿C语言,C语言编程问题用C语言编个学生通讯录管理系统，功能有：①创建通讯 爱问知识人...
- Python程序-打印单词的菱形字符图案
- SpringBoot之kafka安装windows
- 从多态性谈动态联编的必要性（c++）
- 重庆北大青鸟校区【学员心声】：学习是我们前进的动力
- php分组统计求和,数据需求统计常用shell命令---AWK分组求和，分组统计次数
- 北京邮电大学计算机学院合并,北京邮电大学院系重组
- 解决微擎框架出现Could not resolve: cloud.zhifun.cc (Domain name not found)问题
- 华为云空间兑换码在哪里找_华为云空间在哪里找到
- 【新手案例】Python3.7如何获取网络时间
- 《变形金刚ONLINE》策划案
- 【信息汇总】浙江大学计算机考研
- ESP8266 烧写选项 Flash Size 32M和32M-c1的区别
- centos查oracle版本命令,Linux操作系统查看系统信息命令
- POI导出Excel遇到数据量大该如何解决
- Win10日历便签怎么设置定时提醒
- NodeMCU连接天猫精灵第二集——开发环境、运行条件、工作代码（基于Blinker点灯科技）
- windows7系统笔记本设置成虚拟WiFi热点
- 《星际穿越》：一手烧脑一手催泪